Former Phillies’ Hall of Fame chances – Part one: The cameos
Photo by Daniel on Unsplash
The 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot includes seven former Philadelphia Phillies players. In this first part of the series, the author looks at those who only had brief “cameo” stints with the team, noting that if they were elected, their plaques would not show a Phillies cap.
Jake Arrieta
Arrieta’s career totals are 12 seasons, 285 games, 115 wins, a 3.98 ERA, 21.1 WAR, one All‑Star appearance, one Cy Young Award, and three top‑ten Cy Young finishes. He began with the Orioles as a back‑of‑the‑rotation pitcher before being traded to the Cubs, where he won a Cy Young and a World Series. After a short period as a starter, he returned to a supporting role. The Phillies signed him in late 2017 for a three‑year contract, hoping he would anchor the rotation. He was seen by some as a disappointment, but he served as an innings‑eating veteran. The writer predicts Arrieta will receive only a few votes and will likely drop off the ballot quickly, concluding that a single strong season does not merit Hall status.
Jay Bruce
Bruce’s career totals are 14 seasons, a .244/.314/.467 line, 319 home runs, 19.7 WAR, three All‑Star selections, two Silver Slugger awards, and two top‑ten MVP finishes. He began his career with the Reds before moving around the league as a solid, though not elite, slugger. The Phillies acquired him early in the 2019 season to add outfield depth. He produced a short burst of power, but the run did not last, and by 2020 he had become a three‑true‑outcome player. The author expects Bruce to remain on the ballot for another year or so but ultimately will not be inducted, noting that a good career is not enough for Hall of Fame honors.
Asdrúbal Cabrera
Cabrera’s career totals include 15 seasons, a .266/.329/.423 line, 195 home runs, 30 WAR, two All‑Star selections, and one Silver Slugger. He started as a solid shortstop with the Indians before becoming a utility infielder for several clubs. The Phillies traded for him at the end of July 2018, but he posted a –0.7 WAR with the team, and the club finished 23‑38 after his arrival. The writer predicts Cabrera will see only a handful of votes and will not stay on the ballot for long, and he expresses a personal dislike for the player, suggesting that he should not be inducted.
Source: Former Phillies’ Hall of Fame chances – Part one: The cameos
